Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Ruth Gottlieb's avatar

I think you're spot on, and i love this piece. But I'm uncomfortable with your tying the archetypes so tightly to the sexes. I am a woman and a wife and mother, but I am also firmly grounded in reality, honesty, the need for hardship to develop, boundaries, merit - many of the father-aligned traits. I think you would interpret me as someone whose feminine side is balanced with a masculine structure (having a husband and children helped a lot). I have been working with and following a lot of gender- critical people, mostly women, and they are not devouring. But i totally agree that the universities and public schools and medical institutions and government have been captured by the devouring ethos. It seems clear to me that affirmative action for women and rampant fatherlessness played a huge role in this mess. So, I think you're exactly right about the overpowering of our society by the maternal archetype unbalanced by the paternal, but I worry that many (especially feminists) will simply read this as sex stereotyping and miss the deep truth here.

Might you consider writing a companion piece about the results of the paternal/ masculine unfettered by the maternal/ feminine? Islamic states suggest themselves as examples. Might Israel be an example of balance?

Expand full comment
Rosesgrow's avatar

This is a great essay and it very much speaks to my concerns about how this young generation are not being supported to progress beyond a pre-Oedipal level which is characterised by a mother-child dyad where needs are gratified and comfort and safety are prioritised. This is normal and vital for very young children but as the child grows, the presence of the father becomes crucial for psychic growth and development. His involvement both literally and symbolically help a child separate from mother and tolerate ordinary and healthy limits on immediate gratification and need fulfilment. The child is kindly helped to understand that difficult feelings are a necessary part of being human and reality can be painful but also survivable. It is not through having every need gratified or being protected from pain that enable healthy psychic growth and individuation but the tolerance and mastery of reality and the inevitable frustrations and conflicts inherent in this; the painful awareness you are not centre of the world, envy of others, jealousy and rivalry when one is excluded. Life is hard and being human is fraught with conflicts inherent to growing up. Let’s lean into this, accept it and stop over diagnosing.

Expand full comment
26 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?